Black Door Tavern
This place had really fancy, foodie food. They change the menu every two weeks and leave very few items on the list. There was a mushroom tort that was a fan favorite from Tim and the women I went with. Great beer and cocktail selection. A little more expensive and smaller platters. They have limited hours and you may want to make a reservation. They are also directly beside one of the two distilleries in the area, the Red Eagle Distillery.
https://blackdoortavern.com/
6202 South River Road West, Geneva, Ohio 44041